Showing posts with label Environment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Environment. Show all posts

Interesting article on drilling in the arctic

Published September 29, 2010

Cold front opens up in energy race

Opening up the Arctic to economic development is risky. There is already geopolitical conflict brewing in the region

By MATTHEW LYNN

IF WE didn't already have the phrase Cold War, we'd have to invent it to describe the power struggle taking place for Arctic Ocean resources. Companies such as BP Plc and OAO Gazprom are readying themselves for the last great energy frontier.

Russia, the US, Canada, and Iceland are vying for control of the wealth and power that exploitation of the Arctic will create.

It is all madness. Trying to bring the frozen wastelands around the North Pole into the global economy involves two huge risks: catastrophic climate change, and a major war.

It isn't worth it. The world is making progress with alternatives to fossil fuels. It has enough growth opportunities already. There's only one sensible response: a complete ban on the economic exploitation of the Arctic.

The melting of the polar ice cap is providing access to vast, untapped reserves of oil and gas. BP estimated in September last year that the region may contain about 200 billion barrels of oil-equivalent resources. That may be as much as half of the world's hydrocarbons still to be discovered.

BP's recent experience in the Gulf of Mexico might have slightly damped its enthusiasm for offshore drilling. But even if the company doesn't want to tap the Arctic fields, plenty of its competitors will be happy to.

It isn't just oil. The melting of the ice cap may allow direct shipping between Europe and Asia, halving the journey time. New trade routes will mean new ports and transport hubs.

Iceland, bruised from its recent attempts to become a global financial centre, may find its future in trade instead as ships pass through the Arctic.

Throughout history, trade routes have been a great source of wealth. This one won't be any different.

The trouble is, opening up the Arctic to economic development is fraught with risk. There is already geopolitical conflict brewing in the region.

'It is important to maintain a zone of peace and cooperation in the Arctic,' Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin said at the International Arctic Forum in Moscow last week.

'I have no doubt that all issues, including those of the Arctic shelf, can be resolved in the spirit of partnership.' If you believe that, you'll believe anything.

In reality, Russia is pouring huge sums of money into assembling the scientific and geographical evidence that will allow it to push its territory as far into the Arctic as possible.

The world has seen how Mr Putin's Russia uses energy as a weapon of power politics.

That Mr Putin believes Arctic disputes can be resolved amicably is about as plausible as believing he has genuinely handed over power to President Dmitry Medvedev.

In truth, the Russians are planning to grab control of as much of the Arctic as they can. But so are Canada, the US, Iceland, Denmark, and Norway.

If the Chinese can think of some plausible reason for saying it is theirs, no doubt they will be there soon as well.

There are two good reasons to place a ban on Arctic mining. First, climate change. The logic of the energy industry appears to be this: Fossil fuels create global warming, which melts the polar ice cap, which is sort of handy - even though upsetting for the polar bears - because it means that with all that stupid ice out of the way we can start drilling for more oil.

And once we get it out, and start burning it, it will melt the ice some more, and make even more oil accessible.

It's crazy. If the polar ice cap is melting - and the bulk of scientific evidence suggests that it is at a rapid rate - the first thing you need to do is stop drilling for more oil.

True, not everyone is convinced that climate change is man-made. There is room for argument. The scientific consensus has been wrong before, and may have gotten this one tangled up as well.

And yet, given the catastrophic consequences if the consensus is right, why take the risk? Great progress is being made with alternatives to fossil fuels.

Electric cars are on the verge of breaking into the mass market. Wind, solar, and nuclear power are increasingly able to heat our homes and offices.

They are better for the environment, and they don't leave you dependent on people in Moscow or Riyadh to stay warm in winter.

Why not press on with developing those rather than drilling for oil and gas in the Arctic? Second, no one really knows who owns the Arctic.

When it was just a big block of ice, no one really cared. Now that money is at stake, half the world is making claims. In the 19th century, the major European powers competed for control of the resources and trade routes of Africa and Asia. They ended up with World War I.

There is a risk that a similar rush to control the Arctic may trigger another major conflict. Even if it doesn't, competing ambitions will poison relations for years.

A ban on mining and drilling in the Arctic is the only way. For a few more barrels of oil, it's not worth the risk.

Matthew Lynn is a Bloomberg News columnist and the author of 'Bust', a forthcoming book on the Greek debt crisis. The opinions expressed are his own

Who cooked the planet?

Taken from Today Online:

Who cooked the planet?

The culprits are greed and cowardice - and the world will pay the price

Never say that the gods lack a sense of humour. I bet they're still chuckling on Olympus over the decision to make the first half of 2010 - the year in which all hope of action to limit climate change died - the hottest such stretch on record.

Of course, you can't infer trends in global temperatures from one year's experience. But ignoring that fact has long been one of the favourite tricks of climate-change deniers: They point to an unusually warm year in the past, and say: "See, the planet has been cooling, not warming, since 1998!"

Actually, 2005, not 1998, was the warmest year to date - but the point is that the record-breaking temperatures we're currently experiencing have made a nonsense argument even more nonsensical; at this point it doesn't work even on its own terms.

But will any of the deniers say "Okay, I guess I was wrong," and support climate action? No. And the planet will continue to cook.

So why didn't climate-change legislation get through the United States Senate? Let's talk first about what didn't cause the failure because there have been many attempts to blame the wrong people.

First of all, we didn't fail to act because of legitimate doubts about the science.

Every piece of valid evidence - long-term temperature averages that smooth out year-to-year fluctuations, Arctic sea ice volume, melting of glaciers, the ratio of record highs to record lows - points to a continuing, and quite possibly accelerating, rise in global temperatures.

Nor is this evidence tainted by scientific misbehaviour. You've probably heard about the accusations levelled against climate researchers - allegations of fabricated data, the supposedly damning email messages of "Climategate," and so on.

What you may not have heard, because it has received much less publicity, is that every one of these supposed scandals was eventually unmasked as a fraud concocted by opponents of climate action, then bought into the news by many in the media.

Did reasonable concerns about the economic impact of climate legislation block action? No. It has always been funny, in a gallows humour sort of way, to watch conservatives who laud the limitless power and flexibility of markets turn around and insist that the economy would collapse if we were to put a price on carbon.

All serious estimates suggest that we could phase in limits on greenhouse gas emissions with at most a small impact on the economy's growth rate.



FOLLOW THE MONEY

So it wasn't the science, the scientists or the economics that killed action on climate change. What was it?

The answer is, the usual suspects: Greed and cowardice.

If you want to understand opposition to climate action, follow the money. The economy as a whole wouldn't be significantly hurt if we put a price on carbon, but certain industries - above all, the coal and oil industries - would. And those industries have mounted a huge disinformation campaign to protect their bottom lines.

Look at the scientists who question the consensus on climate change; look at the organisations pushing fake scandals; look at the think-tanks claiming that any effort to limit emissions would cripple the economy.

Again and again, you'll find that they're on the receiving end of a pipeline of funding that starts with big energy companies, like Exxon Mobil, which has spent tens of millions of dollars promoting climate-change denial, or Koch Industries, which has been sponsoring anti-environment organisations for two decades.

Or look at the politicians who have been most vociferously opposed to climate action. Where do they get much of their campaign money? You already know the answer.

By itself, however, greed wouldn't have triumphed. It needed the aid of cowardice - above all, the cowardice of politicians who know how big a threat global warming poses, who supported action in the past, but who deserted their posts at the crucial moment.

There are a number of such climate cowards but let me single out one in particular: Senator John McCain.

There was a time when Mr McCain was considered a friend of the environment. Back in 2003 he burnished his maverick image by co-sponsoring legislation that would have created a cap-and-trade system for greenhouse gas emissions.

He reaffirmed support for such a system during his presidential campaign and things might look very different now if he had continued to back climate action once his opponent was in the White House.

But he didn't - and it's hard to see his switch as anything other than the act of a man willing to sacrifice his principles, and humanity's future, for the sake of a few years added to his political career.

Alas, Mr McCain wasn't alone; and there will be no climate Bill. Greed, aided by cowardice, has triumphed. And the whole world will pay the price.



The writer is a professor of economics and international affairs at Princeton University. He received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2008.

http://www.todayonline.com/Commentary/EDC100728-0000042/Who-cooked-the-planet